Avant-Garde Metal

In honor of the newly-reunited Mr. Bungle playing their first shows in 20 years, I felt it was only necessary to pay homage to one of my personal favorite subgenres of metal music: avant-garde metal. Originating from the French word for 'vanguard,' what makes avant-garde metal (and experimental music in general) is how undefinable it can be. Hell, the very terminology for the genre implies less of a unified sound, but rather just 'these bands don't go in any other category. Lump all the weirdos together.' In doing so, metal's wackiest, zaniest, and most experimental genre came to be.

Some styles of music are considered experimental or avant-garde when they first rear their heads in the scene, but will eventually become more standardized and commonplace as the trend catches on, thus rendering their application of the avant-garde term obsolete. This happens a lot, particularly in such a forward-thinking genre as metal, so the degree to which something I discuss here is considered 'avant-garde' may be variable. Take that into consideration when reading.

Avant-garde metal took its first steps in the late 1980s with a trifecta of bands who were doing things differently: Warning, Celtic Frost, and Old (then-stylized as O.L.D.). Old was an odd bunch of folks playing industrial metal-tinged grindcore with a healthy dash of experimental rock. Celtic Frost was a legendary thrash metal band that decided to take a turn for the weirder with their 1987 opus Into the Pandemonium. Warning was arguably the first band to be classified as avant-garde metal, with a very odd blend of progressive electronic music and doom metal. Also in the 1980s was the creation of the legendary Mr. Bungle. Though the collective only released a handful of demos and EPs that were in much more of a conventional thrash metal/death metal style, Mr. Bungle would soon become one of the most prominent figures in the entire genre.

As humanity entered the 1990s, avant-garde metal really got the opportunity to spread its wings. Collaborations of unconventional sounds, structures, and instrumentation began to pop up in seemingly every facet of the metal community in spurts of vanguard weirdness. Black metal and symphonic metal bands like Ved Buens Ende, Arcturus, Sigh, and Graal began to flourish. Avant-garde death metal such as Gorguts, Pan.Thy.Monium, and Pestilence began to arrive based out of more boundary-pushing offshoots of technical death metal. Bands like Naked City and PainKiller delved into dark ambient and avant-garde jazz territory in their works. Even stranger still was the introduction of funk rock and alternative metal into the fray, most notably showcased on Mr. Bungle's self-titled debut record.

Most prominent within the scene was the overlap with progressive metal. Progressive metal, being a genre focused similarly around pushing the envelope and watching it bend, tends to overlap with a lot of avant-garde metal. However, I find that the key distinguishing feature between the two can be summed up with 'weirdness.' Progressive metal bands like Dream Theater, Between the Buried and Me, and Opeth all take the metal formula and push it beyond its established limits to create something more forward-focused, as do experimental metal bands. However, say where a progressive metal band would tend to use elements of Western classical music to add textures or layers, an avant-metal band would potentially incorporate purely chamber music-based instrumentals underneath harsh death or doom metal vocals and lyricism. Where progressive music focuses on technicality, musicality, and virtuosity of its players, experimental music relies far more on how far they can take the music in any one direction at a time. Key bands from the '90s that showcased this overlap include maudlin of the Well, In the Woods..., Solefald, and Thought Industry.

Recommended '90s avant-garde metal listening (plus one '80s album):
1. Celtic Frost - Into the Pandemonium (1987)
2. Mr. Bungle - Mr. Bungle (1991)
3. Ved Buens Ende - Written in Waters (1995)
4. Arcturus - La masquerade infernale (1997)
5. Gorguts - Obscura (1998)

Once the 2000s hit, avant-metal began to really boom. Major players began to take shape, such as the monumental 2001 releases Bath and Leaving Your Body Map from maudlin of the Well, Toby Driver's subsequent act Kayo Dot, noisecore-forerunners Today is the Day, Mike Patton of Mr. Bungle's new project Fantômas, Dir en Grey, Sleepytime Gorilla Museum, Thy Catafalque, Dog Fashion Disco, Ephel Duath, Diablo Swing Orchestra, Stolen Babies, Unexpect, and phenomenal new works from established acts such as Arcturus, Solefald, and Sigh. New waves of zany, chaotic avant-garde metal known more specifically as 'circus metal' started to take form, which has inadvertently caused many folks nowadays to label any metal with circus sounds, vibes or themes as avant-garde.

Recommended '00s avant-garde metal listening:
1. Fantômas - The Director's Cut (2001)
2. Sigh - Imaginary Sonicscape (2001)
3. maudlin of the Well - Bath / Leaving Your Body Map (2001)
4. Arcturus - The Sham Mirrors (2002)
5. Sleepytime Gorilla Museum - Of Natural History (2004)

In the 2010s, some progressive metal acts began to incorporate more and more avant-garde elements into their sound, as seen primarily in some works by the great Devin Townsend. Other fusions between the two were carried by the Norwegian band Shining, Ex Eye, and the usual releases from Thy Catafalque, Dir en Grey, Kayo Dot (which now dabbles mostly in art rock and avant-prog), and Diablo Swing Orchestra. Avant-garde black metal still burns strong, with newcomers to the genre coming out of the atmospheric black metal woodworks like Blut aus Nord, A Forest of Stars, Liturgy, Imperial Triumphant, Hail Spirit Noir (combining avant-black metal with psychedelic rock), Schammasch, and Howls of Ebb. Multi-instrumentalist Igorrr has led a recent surge in breakcore-inspired metal music. Odder still is the relative mainstream success of Zeal & Ardor, a band which combines avant-garde black metal with slave spirituals.

Recommended '10s avant-garde metal listening:
1. Devin Townsend Project - Deconstruction (2011)
2. Thy Catafalque - Rengeteg (2011)
3. Diablo Swing Orchestra - Pandora's Piñata (2012)
4. Blut aus Nord - 777: Cosmosophy (2012)
5. Kayo Dot - Hubardo (2013)

If there were ever to be a metal genre that had an inexhaustible pool of creativity, it would have to be avant-garde metal. Simply by nature, avant-garde metal cannot move forward if it conforms. Individual bands may get snippets of recognition or (in very rare cases) even airplay, but things will never stay stagnant for long, lest the bands be swept into a more grounded genre and lose what made them experimental, artful, and so avant-garde in the first place. A genre term built purely around incomprehensible genre tagging, genre hopping, and genre defying artists... it's pretty much an oxymoron. And a glorious one, at that.